<< back to blog

Handheld recorders for musicians and podcasters


28 May, 2008

I've been using a dictaphone for recording song ideas and jam sessions for a while now. It's quick, very portable and does the job well. However, I'm now looking for something that gets a better sound quality. Here's some notes on current recorders out there.

Mark Nelson at O'Reilly has done some great articles on portable recorders, where I got my info from.

There is also a comparison chart and more great articles on these devices at Transom

Sony PCM-D50 * Review and sample recordings by Mark Nelson * Price: £320 ($640) * Size: 73 x 155 x 34 mm (384) (Looks chunky, but holdable in one hand. Probably too big for pocket.) * Weight: 365.1g * Pros: Beautiful sound quality. Good limiter. * Cons: Larger that I'd like. Windshield costs extra. * Summary: "To sum up: the Sony PCM-D50 is everything a field recorder should be. Although it might appear expensive compared to some of the others, consider that you get four gigs of memory included, robust construction, excellent mics, and a number of useful features ported over from its upscale cousin. If you're serious about field recording, the D50 is well worth your consideration."

Olympus LS-10 * Review and sample recordings by Mark Nelson * Transom Review * Price: £240 ($480) * Size: 131.5 x 48 x 22.4 mm (141) (looks very small, like a regular small dictaphone) * Weight: 165g * Summary: "To my ears the LS-10 did a good job capturing the thump of my big Taylor flattop. There's plenty of high-end detail, though it's not as smooth as I'd like, and I can hear a little hiss creeping in as the guitar trails off. Nonetheless, I think the LS-10 does as good a job recording music and voice as some recorders costing quite a bit more." "I like the Olympus LS-10 a lot. I'm tickled with the design, ergonomics, audio quality, and the rugged aluminum case. I even like the little carrying case; it's just big enough for the recorder and a mini tripod."

Marantz PMD620 * Review and sample recordings by Mark Nelson * Price: * Size: 102 x 62 x 25 (size of a deck of cards) * Weight: 110g (+ battery) * Pros: Optional cool remote that mounds on a mic for one handed operation * Cons: Good, but not great music recording. Good for voice. * Summary: "When all is said and done the PMD620 is a contender. Once you've taken the time to create your presets, it is sublimely easy to use. It does a good job recording outdoors; handles music recording reasonably well; and has a number of useful features for interviewing, podcasts, and other voice work."

Zoom H2 * Review and sample recordings by Mark Nelson * Price: £140 ($280) * Size: Handheld, but again not tiny * Weight: * Pros: Mini tripod included. Can use all 4 internal mics at once * Cons: Bad with external mics * Summary:

Zoom H4 * Review and samples * Price: £220

Korg MR-1 * Review and sample recordings my Mark Nelson * Price: £405 ($810)

Edirol R-09 * Review and samples * Price: £220 * Weight: 170g * Pros: Great, all round handlheld recorder for most situations. * Cons: Not as much pro detail in the sound.

You may also like...
Simplest User Interface Ever (humour)
Bruce Springsteen at Old Trafford
Handheld recorders for musicians and podcasters

kick it on DotNetKicks.com
blog comments powered by Disqus